Key takeaways
- A vendor that records visits and drafts notes creates, receives and maintains PHI, which makes it a HIPAA business associate.
- HHS treats de-identifying PHI as a use, so a scribe vendor may de-identify recordings for its own purposes only if the agreement permits it.
- California Penal Code section 632 bars recording a confidential communication without the consent of all parties.
- Audio and transcripts used to make decisions about patients can fall within the designated record set that patients have a right to access.
- The proposed Security Rule would require annual written safeguard verification from business associates, and it was not final as of November 2026.
Ambient AI scribes listen to a patient visit, transcribe it and draft the clinical note before the patient leaves. For a small practice or a nonprofit health program, that can cut the time clinicians spend on documentation. Whether a tool works as a HIPAA compliant AI scribe depends largely on the agreement behind it. It also places a recording of one of the most sensitive conversations a person has into a vendor's cloud, and HIPAA has specific things to say about that.
None of the HIPAA rules below were written with AI in mind. They apply anyway. The Privacy Rule, the Security Rule and the Breach Notification Rule cover any vendor that handles protected health information (PHI) for you, and an AI scribe handles a great deal of it.
Is an AI scribe vendor a HIPAA business associate?
An AI scribe vendor is a HIPAA business associate in almost every deployment. HIPAA defines a business associate as a person or company that creates, receives, maintains or transmits PHI on behalf of a covered entity (45 CFR 160.103). A scribe that records a visit, stores the audio and returns a draft note does all four.
HHS has also said that a cloud service storing electronic PHI is a business associate even when it cannot read the data (HHS guidance on HIPAA and cloud computing). A vendor's assurance that audio is encrypted or deleted quickly does not change its status.
Most scribe products also send audio or text to a separate AI model provider. That provider is a subcontractor, and the scribe vendor needs written assurances from it before PHI flows downstream (45 CFR 164.502(e) and 164.308(b)). Ask the vendor to name every subcontractor that touches your data.
What should the business associate agreement for an AI scribe cover?
A business associate agreement for an AI scribe needs every term HIPAA requires of any business associate agreement, plus clear written answers on how the vendor uses your data. The required terms are in 45 CFR 164.504(e) and 164.314(a): permitted uses, safeguards, incident and breach reporting, flow-down to subcontractors, support for patient access requests, and return or destruction of PHI when the contract ends.
For AI scribes, four topics deserve explicit language:
- Model training. A business associate may use PHI only as its agreement permits. HHS treats de-identifying PHI as a use, so a vendor may de-identify your recordings for its own product development only if the agreement allows it (HHS FAQ on de-identification by business associates).
- Retention. How long the vendor keeps audio files, transcripts and draft notes, and where. Deleting audio once the note is signed shrinks what a breach could expose.
- Subcontractors. Which AI model providers receive audio or text, and whether each has an agreement with the vendor.
- Breach timing. HIPAA requires a business associate to notify you of a breach without unreasonable delay and no later than 60 calendar days after discovery (45 CFR 164.410). Agreements can set a shorter window.
Does a patient have to agree to being recorded?
HIPAA itself does not require a patient's written authorization for a scribe used in treatment. The Privacy Rule permits disclosures to a business associate for treatment and health care operations under a compliant agreement. State recording laws are a separate question, and California's is strict.
California Penal Code section 632 prohibits recording a confidential communication without the consent of all parties (Cal. Penal Code § 632). The statute defines a confidential communication as one carried on in circumstances that reasonably indicate a party wants it confined to the parties. Section 637.2 lets a person recorded in violation sue.
A workable consent process asks at the start of each visit, records the answer in the chart, and gives clinicians a simple way to switch the scribe off when a patient declines or the conversation turns sensitive. If you see patients in other states or by telehealth, the counsel review list below covers what to confirm.
Are AI scribe recordings and transcripts part of the medical record?
Whether AI scribe recordings and transcripts belong in the medical record depends on how your clinicians use them, so decide before go-live. HIPAA's designated record set includes medical records and any other records used to make decisions about individuals (45 CFR 164.501). Patients have a right to inspect and get copies of PHI in the designated record set (45 CFR 164.524).
The signed note is part of the medical record. Raw audio and unedited transcripts are less clear. If clinicians return to the audio to make care decisions, it starts to look like part of the designated record set. If the vendor deletes it once the note is signed, there is little left to produce.
Write the decision into your policies, set vendor retention to match, and make sure the agreement requires the vendor to help you answer access requests for anything it keeps.
How does an AI scribe change your HIPAA risk analysis?
An AI scribe adds a system that captures ePHI in a new form, so your HIPAA risk analysis has to cover it. The Security Rule requires an accurate and thorough assessment of risks to all ePHI you create, receive, maintain or transmit (45 CFR 164.308(a)(1)(ii)(A)). OCR continues to cite missing or incomplete risk analyses in its enforcement actions, including four ransomware settlements announced in April 2026 (HHS OCR press release).
For a scribe, the analysis should look at:
- Capture devices: clinic phones, personal phones, tablets and exam-room microphones, and whether each is managed and encrypted.
- Accounts: whether each clinician has a unique login (45 CFR 164.312(a)) and whether multi-factor authentication is required.
- Integration: how drafts reach the electronic health record and what permissions the connection holds.
- Activity review: whether you can see who opened which recordings and notes, and whether anyone reviews those records (45 CFR 164.308(a)(1)(ii)(D)).
A draft signed without review still becomes part of the medical record. Decide who reviews drafts and how errors get corrected. Keep the risk analysis and the policies behind these decisions for six years (45 CFR 164.316(b)).
Would the proposed Security Rule changes affect AI scribes?
The proposed Security Rule changes would affect AI scribe deployments if they are finalized. HHS proposed a broad update to the Security Rule on January 6, 2025 (90 FR 898), and it had not been finalized as of November 2026. The proposal would require a technology asset inventory and a map of how ePHI moves through your systems, updated at least every 12 months. It would also require business associates to give covered entities written verification, at least every 12 months, that required technical safeguards are in place (HHS fact sheet).
A scribe deployment would appear in both. The capture devices and vendor platform belong in the inventory, and the vendor would owe you an annual verification. Building these records now costs little and makes a final rule easier to absorb. For the latest on timing, see where the HIPAA Security Rule update stands, and for the inventory itself, how to prepare a HIPAA asset inventory and network map.
What should you do to keep an AI scribe HIPAA compliant this quarter?
To keep an AI scribe HIPAA compliant, start with the scribe tools already in use, then set the rules for anything new:
- List every AI scribe or note tool in use, including free trials clinicians signed up for on their own. Our guide to finding AI tools touching PHI outside your agreements covers the methods.
- Confirm a signed business associate agreement for each tool, and read the sections on training, retention and subcontractors.
- Set and document retention for audio, transcripts and drafts, and decide whether any of them belong in the designated record set.
- Put a consent script and a chart field in place, and give clinicians a quick way to pause recording.
- Add the scribe to your risk analysis and asset inventory, and limit sign-in to managed devices with multi-factor authentication.
- If PHI has already gone into a tool without an agreement, run a breach risk assessment. This walkthrough explains the four factors.
What should your counsel review before you turn on an AI scribe?
Have counsel review your AI scribe setup before you sign the vendor's agreement or switch on recording in any exam room, and again before you extend the scribe to telehealth or patients in another state. Bring these decisions:
- Whether your consent process meets California Penal Code section 632 and the recording laws of every other state where you see patients in person or by telehealth. Bring the consent script, the chart field and a list of the states where your patients are located.
- Whether the business associate agreement meets 45 CFR 164.504(e) and 164.314(a) and states what the vendor may do with your PHI, including de-identification for model training. Bring the agreement, the vendor's terms of service and its list of subcontractors.
- Whether audio, transcripts and drafts fall within your designated record set under 45 CFR 164.501, and how long state law requires you to keep medical records. Bring your retention policy and the vendor's retention settings.
How can s90 help?
s90 helps organizations in Los Angeles and Orange County that handle PHI show that their technology would hold up if OCR or an auditor asked. If clinicians have started using an AI scribe and you are not sure what the vendor does with the recordings, or whether your risk analysis covers it, our Compliance: HIPAA service is built for that gap. We help you check scribe vendors against HIPAA's business associate requirements, lock down capture devices and accounts, and keep the risk analysis, asset inventory and vendor records current. Each quarter you receive a Compliance Posture Report showing who can reach health information and whether each safeguard is working. If you are weighing an AI scribe, we are happy to talk through what your setup would need.

